I finally found a way to accomplish this, and it came in the form of this beautiful YouTube clip:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f_P1PPy7FTo
I had already shown her another one where Puddles got in a fight with Houston Cougar's mascot. That had sparked her interest because as she noted, that duck had edge.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d6dd6/d6dd6dccd0320022978fcfc202ab28d8ae6832a6" alt=""
Totally dominated
But she was truly swayed when she saw the Return of the Quack. All I had to do was show this to Alex, and she was hooked. I returned home that night and was told that she had not only watched that video several times, but had also searched for other duck videos to enjoy. She stumbled upon a bunch of other good ones, but I still think that this one remains at the top of her favorites list.
Now it seems that every day when I get home there are new pictures of Puddles popping up everywhere from the background on her computer and phone, to our wall of pictures in our room.
I have never seen her so excited to watch a football game as she was last night when we watched UCLA fall to Oregon 60-13. She watched the whole thing, while i fell asleep (I'm not exactly 100% healthy right now, that's my story and I'm sticking to it).
Anyways, I leave you with this parting image:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/db6b5/db6b521fbc03c2c94633a6dd4ba9a54266769cca" alt=""
How can you not love that face?